Manchester United’s Pursuit of Matthijs de Ligt: A Misguided Venture?

As the summer transfer window heats up, Manchester United’s pursuit of Bayern Munich defender Matthijs de Ligt has been making headlines. However, not everyone is convinced that the 24-year-old Dutchman is the right fit for the Red Devils. In fact, Liverpool legend Phil Thompson has gone on record to suggest that United should be looking elsewhere, specifically at Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite.

‘Matthijs de Ligt is a good player, but when I look at Manchester United, I feel like they need a player who knows the Premier League,’ Thompson told Paddy Power.

Thompson’s concerns are not unfounded. United’s recent experience with Raphael Varane, who struggled to adapt to the Premier League after his move from Real Madrid, serves as a cautionary tale. De Ligt, who has spent the last two seasons in Germany with Bayern Munich, may face similar challenges.

On the other hand, Branthwaite, a 22-year-old England defender, has already proven himself in the Premier League with Everton. His familiarity with the league and his impressive performances for the Toffees make him an attractive alternative to De Ligt.

Manchester United’s defensive woes continue to plague the team

United’s need for a new centre-back is undeniable. With Varane’s departure, Erik ten Hag’s side is in dire need of a reliable defender who can partner with Harry Maguire. However, the question remains whether De Ligt is the right man for the job.

Jarrad Branthwaite in action for Everton

Thompson’s suggestion that United should prioritize Branthwaite over De Ligt is not without merit. The young English defender has already shown his potential in the Premier League, and his ability to adapt to United’s system could be less of a gamble than bringing in De Ligt.

Erik ten Hag’s Manchester United looks to strengthen its defense

As the transfer window continues to unfold, it will be interesting to see whether United will heed Thompson’s advice and pursue Branthwaite instead of De Ligt. One thing is certain, however: United’s defense needs a major overhaul, and the right signing could make all the difference in their quest for Premier League glory.